The founder of Yearn finance, Andre Cronje, has seen a fair share of criticism lately as he deployed some smart contracts that ended up losing people money. Cronje defended himself in a blog post and explained why he believes he shouldn’t be held responsible for those who “ape in” his testing contracts.
Cronje will often place large disclaimers urging people to treat them with caution and not just go in because he built it. Little can be done to prevent this, given the permissionless nature of these products. Nevertheless, Cronje was sometimes criticized for not deploying contracts on testnets, where no real money could be lost. His “I test in prod” adage also turns some people away, as it seems to imply a careless attitude toward security.
Cronje explained that he does in fact test software in multiple stages. “[The statement] exists to deter people from just using systems without investigation. It does NOT mean that I don’t test,” he wrote.
Before a contract makes it to the mainnet, it goes through a rigorous process of unit, interaction and composite testing. These make sure that each part of the contract is working as intended, down to individual functions.
However, a key part of that process is testing in production to achieve the most realistic conditions. He explained that the mainnet provides the best possible tools and conditions, which cannot easily be replicated locally. “I have discovered issues on mainnet I never encountered locally, I have failed to replicate mainnet systems locally, and I have encountered errors locally that I can’t replicate on mainnet,” he explained.
Furthermore, there are many versions of existing products like Yearn Finance that were deployed to mainnet without getting discovered. “There are over ~22 ‘yearns’ on ETH mainnet. There are over ~5 ‘YFIs’ on ETH mainnet,” he added. In a conversation with Cointelegraph, Cronje said that the reason why his primary projects were never hacked was, “ironically, because I test in prod.” With this approach he says he is able to iterate over the real issues that come up, instead of relying on auditors to review pre-production code. “And if people just wait till I actually launch the product, all will be fine,” he added.
One case of people getting burned on Cronje’s smart contracts involved one of these testing playgrounds, which were still at least a few weeks away from public release.
Addressing these issues, Cronje noted, “I don’t build for speculators.” While he said that he could not rationally understand the people who rushed into his test environments, he seems to have conceded that a more pragmatic approach may be needed. “I have more thinking to do on this,” he concluded.
In the meantime, he pledged to not use his well-known deployer address to conduct further tests. Given the number of previous contracts that went undiscovered, this may be enough to prevent further unfortunate occurrences.
The post follows another instance of people losing money over one of his contracts, an unnamed project often referred to by its token ticker, LBI. The contract was deployed on mainnet on Oct. 13, immediately triggering a torrent of people putting their money in it — often saying that it’s “the new YFI.”
It was not the new YFI. Source: ChartEx
The token’s price fell immediately after, with many stories of people losing small fortunes over it. A barrage of criticism against Cronje was levied by many market participants, blaming him for the loss. It’s worth noting that this price decline was not the result of any kind of malfunction, as the contracts themselves were not compromised.
The price of Solana (SOL) has soared 40% this week to establish a new 2023 high at around $58. That is Solana's best weekly performance since January 2023. Many factors have contributed to the gains, including a general cryptocurrency market uptrend led by Bitcoin ETF euphoria and growing appetite for risk overall.Solana (SOL) weekly price chart. Source: TradingViewFTX-dump
Minnesota state Senator Jeremy Miller has made his state the latest to float investing in Bitcoin after he went “from being highly skeptical” to a crypto believer. 644 Total views 1 Total shares Minnesota state Senator Jeremy Miller has introduced the Minnesota Bitcoin Act, which he drafted after completely changing his stance on Bitcoin. “As
China's Great Firewall, a tool used to ban Chinese citizens from using sites like Google and Facebook, has listed a major explorer for Ethereum’s (ETH) blockchain.According to data from non-profit monitoring organization GreatFire, China allegedly blocked one of the most popular ETH block browsers, Etherscan, in October 2019. As of Dec. 3, Etherscan’s domain remained…
Four malicious hackers and one white-hat have gone to town on ForceDAO during its launch day. 4197 Total views 21 Total shares Fledgling decentralized finance protocol ForceDAO has had a rough start, with several incursions from hackers taking place just hours after it launched.The Ethereum-based yield aggregator had only just launched its airdrop campaign on…
South Carolina Senator Tim Scott, the leader of the US Senate Banking Committee, plans to introduce a bill on March 6 to end regulatory oversight of customer reputational risks toward banks, paving the way for an end to a discriminatory practice known as “debanking,” according to a report from The Wall Street Journal. Debanking is
Discover platforms offering crypto-backed mortgages, allowing you to use digital assets like BTC and ETH to finance real estate purchases without selling your holdings.
Following the Nitro upgrade, activity on Arbitrum has surged and has nearly two-thirds of the transaction activity seen on the Ethereum base layer. 342 Total views 27 Total shares Ethereum layer-2 scaling solution Arbitrum has seen a massive surge in activity since its Nitro update in August, having just clocked around 62% as many transactions…
The State Department should submit a report on the use of cryptocurrencies as a viable reward payout with evidence that suggests it's more encouraging for whistleblowers. Own this piece of crypto history Collect this article as NFTThe United States lawmakers have proposed an amendment to the State Department Basic Authorities Act of 1956 that includes…
The proposal would affect retail transactions carried out from crypto wallets, but not crypto trading. 215 Total views 2 Total shares The United States Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) has proposed a rule to allow it to supervise large non-bank digital wallet and app providers. The rule is part of a larger move by the