A recent plummet in hash rate and spike in transaction fees has raised some questions about Bitcoin’s resilience. But they shouldn’t.
Over the weekend, the Bitcoin hash rate dropped off a cliff, leaving many industry participants wondering what had happened. Over the last couple of days, information and context has been provided by industry experts as to what was behind this steep fall in hash rate.
For instance, this Twitter thread by Mustafa Yilham does a great job explaining the current situation.
TLDR: A large amount of Bitcoin miners in the Xinjiang region had to shut off their machines, due to a water leakage in a coal mining plant that led the central and local governments in China to temporarily shut down operations at other coal mining operations. As it is still the “dry season” in China, a majority of Bitcoin mining operations leverage under-utilized/over-supplied electricity sources, of which a majority in China (about 80%) are currently located in the Xinjiang province, where the shutdowns were occurring.
Recent drop in Bitcoin hash rate
While a plummet in hash rate caused by regulations in a single country left many worried about the resilience of the Bitcoin network, the response was largely an overreaction to a small sample size of slow blocks, early in a difficulty adjustment.
The Bitcoin network has a difficulty adjustment every 2,016 blocks, which calibrates the network in order to have blocks mined at an average time of one every 10 minutes. For example, if blocks came in at a speed of once every nine minutes over the last 2,016 blocks (or about two weeks), then the difficulty would adjust upwards by 10% in order to make it slightly more challenging to mine an additional block.
Difficulty adjustment live calculator by https://diff.cryptothis.com/
A Viral Loop Of Incentives
What is the impact of a large amount of hash power leaving the network? Does this pose a threat to the long-term security model of the Bitcoin network?
Let’s dig into the viral loop of incentives built into the Bitcoin protocol.
When a large proportion of hash rate shuts off, the pace at which blocks are mined subsequently slows down. The result of this is that fewer transactions are confirmed on the blockchain, and the Bitcoin mempool fills with unconfirmed transactions. Blockspace on the Bitcoin network is a scarce resource, and if you wish to use the protocol and the settlement assurances that come with it, you need to pay up.
Recent surge in transaction costs as seen on https://mempool.space/
The mempool works somewhat like an auction block. Transitions all come with an attached fee, and miners select the highest-paying fees to include if/when they mine a block, which is their direct economic incentive. As a result of lagging hash rate over recent days, along with increasing demand to utilize the Bitcoin network, total miner revenue has reached all-time highs.
Daily miner revenue hit an all-time high of $77,500,000 on April 16, 2021
Slower blocks lead to fewer transactions, which lead to higher transaction fees, which lead to larger miner profits, which incentivizes additional miners to participate and join the network, which increases hash rate into the future, which increases network security and the settlement assurances of the protocol.
Additionally, a consistent high-fee environment on the Bitcoin blockchain incentivizes the development of scaling solutions like the Lightning Network. Plus, regardless of what happens with miners joining or leaving the network, after a 2,016 block period, the difficulty will adjust downwards or upwards exactly proportional to the amount of how slow or fast blocks were mined compared to a 10-minute average target.
The Bitcoin network is working exactly as designed, and in a world of entropy, the incentive structure of the protocol ensures that blocks will continue to be mined, and thatthe most robust network on the planet will continue to operate with near 100% uptime.
This article is featured in Bitcoin Magazine’s “The Withdrawal Issue”. Click here to subscribe now.A PDF pamphlet of this article is available for download. Self custody is an essential requirement when using Bitcoin to fully benefit from all the properties that make Bitcoin valuable in the first place. To be able to truly transact without permission
United States Secretary of State Mike Pompeo shared his thoughts on bitcoin and cryptocurrencies in general during an appearance on CNBC’s Squawk Box on August 20, 2019. In essence, the career military man and former CIA director wants them treated like anything else in the global financial arena. Connecting Bitcoin to Terrorism “You’re going to…
Bitcoin remains the undisputed “king” of blockchains. Bitcoin’s dominance has increased significantly since the experimental times of 2017. Bitcoin has survived many attempted forks and “civil wars” and has established itself as the reserve cryptocurrency; people fall back to Bitcoin in bear markets. The production network has stood the test of time for over 10…
Seven years ago today, Bitcoin pioneer Hal Finney passed away from complications of ALS. He’ll always be remembered for “running bitcoin.”Seven years ago today, legendary computer programmer and recipient of the first-ever Bitcoin transaction Hal Finney passed away as a result of complications of ALS.Finney worked as a video game developer and then as a…
The Premier League club created a new fund with the donation with the goal to enhance the experience of its fans.Betting platform Sportsbet.io donated 2 bitcoin to Premier League football club Southampton.The donation set up a new fund that seeks to "support the causes that matter most to [Southampton's] fans," the company said in a…
On December 4, 2018, our CEO, David Bailey, made an exciting announcement: Bitcoin Magazine would be returning to its roots and shifting its focus to Bitcoin-related stories only. As the title of his blog post states, we intend to “Make Bitcoin Fun Again.” What does this mean? To begin with, we are delighted to unveil…
The below is an excerpt from a recent edition of Bitcoin Magazine Pro, Bitcoin Magazine's premium markets newsletter. To be among the first to receive these insights and other on-chain bitcoin market analysis straight to your inbox, subscribe now. This week’s topicsMonumental SEC failureBitcoin ETF multipleGerman economic updateTaiwan elections and China responseSEC’s 2FA FailureBitcoin is
Chinese sports lottery site 500.com has acquired major bitcoin mining pool BTC.com.With 4.3 million bitcoin mining machines running on the network, Whatsminer’s founder predicts the Bitcoin hash rate will reach 120 exahashes by the end of 2019.Today, Shenzhen, China-based sports lottery site 500.com announced the acquisition of major Bitcoin mining pool BTC.com from Blockchain Alliance…
Certain users have received emails detailing their new access to purchase and sell bitcoin on the Fidelity platform.Fidelity, one of the world’s largest financial services providers, has officially started opening retail bitcoin trading accounts. The development comes after their announcement of a wait list previously this month. According to a report by The Block, certain…